What price fairness?


Hey Reader, in today's edition:

  • Higher fixed network charges put up for debate
  • Missing tradies, specialists and IT experts
  • Meters explained

Fixed charges redux

A pricing proposal killed off more than a decade ago has been put back on the table as policymakers consider how best to recover network costs in a consumer-led future.

Energy Consumers Australia has suggested higher fixed network charges levied across all consumers. It argues such a move would improve equity, ensuring network costs can’t be avoided by households or small businesses with a battery.

But others, including consumer and energy efficiency advocates, say it would cause serious collateral damage and there are other options available.

Expert view

"Some fixed charging for energy networks is appropriate and standard practice. Shifting most or all network charging to fixed charging is likely to create social, economic, and emissions problems, including:

Equity issues: Fixed charges are inherently regressive as they disproportionately impact low-income and low-consumption households. Everyone pays the same amount, regardless of how little electricity they use. This means poorer households - who typically use less energy - end up paying far more per kilowatt-hour than wealthier, high-consumption households.

Discourages distributed energy and efficiency: Because the fixed portion of the bill can't be reduced by using less electricity or generating renewable energy, the return on CER shrinks, and the motivation to invest in energy efficiency declines. This delays the transition to a cleaner, smarter grid and penalises households trying to save energy and reduce their environmental footprint.

Poor network incentives leading to uncontrolled growth in energy costs and bills: Fixed charges ignore the true cost of using the grid during peak times, especially in light of growing demand from electrification. Instead of incentivising users to shift or reduce demand when the grid is strained - which would help avoid expensive network upgrades - these charges decouple household behaviour from cost signals.”

Craig Memery
Senior Advisor, Energy & Water Justice, Justice and Equity Centre

Missing tradies, specialists and IT experts

An extra 22,000 apprentices should have been on the tools last year to meet the workforce needs of the renewables transition and green manufacturing boom. (AAP)

“What is often misunderstood in the system is that everyone wants to hire a trained electrician, but no one wants to train the electrician.”
Anthea Middleton
Powering Skills Organisation CEO

The Powering Skills Organisation's Workforce Plan out this week offers some actions to shift the dial:

  • A national register for apprentices who want to train to connect directly with employers
  • A national strategy to support career influencers and promote trades pathways
  • Better understanding and defining the apprenticeship value proposition for employers
  • Early year apprentice quotas on major projects – especially large businesses
  • Evaluate existing initiatives to increase number of trainers
  • A grants program for Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) to invest in training infrastructure

Expert view

"Australia’s energy transition relies not only on the physical infrastructure we build, but equally on the skilled people who design, install, and manage it.

Shortages aren’t limited to trade roles; they’re most acute in specialist engineering, systems integration, and digital roles essential for delivering complex, multi-asset grids.

Our education pipeline isn’t keeping pace. Universities and VET institutions aren’t producing enough graduates in critical disciplines, forcing industry to retrain, upskill, and reshuffle skilled workers between projects.

What are the solutions? Firstly, implement a coordinated national energy workforce plan with buy-in from governments, industry bodies, unions, and education providers to set clear targets.

Secondly, accelerate supply with funded engineering places, paid industry placements, funded apprenticeships, and flexible mid-career pathways to attract adjacent talent.

Finally, leverage skilled migration to bridge gaps while building homegrown expertise, especially in regional areas facing shortfalls.

Skilled workforces aren’t optional; they’re essential. Whether boosting grid resilience, meeting rising power demands or advancing low-carbon solutions, the energy transition will only succeed if we supercharge our workforce alongside our infrastructure.”

Charlie Jewkes
Managing Director of Water, Power & Energy, WSP Australia

Meters explained

Electricity meters have typically been a means to determine household energy bills, but as technology and consumer needs evolve they’re being used for new reasons.

With that comes more regulatory oversight, and in The Energy’s latest explainer Griffith University’s Phillip Wild and Nancy Spencer detail the what and why.

Catch Up

Capital

Losses from a trouble-plagued refinery that IGO (ASX: IGO) says has “no pathway” to making money and woeful lithium prices left the battery minerals firm in the red and investors without a dividend. Its primary asset is a stake in the world’s largest hard rock lithium mine Greenbushes, located 250km south of Perth. The miner plunged from a narrow $3 million profit in FY2024 to a $955 million net loss in FY25. (The West)

“The global lithium market was weak throughout FY25. Nevertheless, Greenbushes demonstrated it is a world class asset with an EBITDA margin of 66% and strong cash conversion. We believe market fundamentals for lithium are positive and Greenbushes is well placed to capitalise.”
Ivan Vella
IGO CEO

Lynas Rare Earths (ASX: LYC) launched an $825 million capital raising to develop its Mount Weld carbonatite facility to produce higher-grade neodymium and praseodymium (NdPr) used in the manufacture of high-performance magnets found in EVs and wind turbines. (AFR)


Projects

Potentia Energy’s $400 million battery project at Emeroo is the first Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) to be granted environmental approval under South Australia’s new legislation, the Hydrogen and Renewable Energy Act, which took effect last year. Co-located with the existing Bungala Solar Farm, the 225MW BESS required a Statement of Environmental Objectives (SEO).

“Securing this significant milestone under South Australia’s HRE Act is a significant achievement for both Potentia Energy and the state. This new legislation is just one aspect of South Australia’s forward thinking, which is why other states are looking to it as a model for pioneering work in the transition to cleaner energy.”
Werther Esposito
Potentia Energy CEO

Policy

“We all know a carbon price is first best policy but that statement gets us nowhere,” Professor Rod Sims said in a speech to the NSW Treasury and Economic Society of NSW. Sims called for an easy to communicate carbon pricing approach such as a Carbon Solutions Levy (CSL) that would replace “an array of current defective policies” and compensate all but the largest users of electricity. A CSL levied only on 108 sites of fossil fuel production could also smooth the way for the removal of tax breaks for diesel use. If levied at the same rate as the European carbon price, he said it would raise around $20 billion per annum for budget repair or supporting low-carbon industries of the future.

“The following arguments are why a carbon price is necessary and urgent: First, our current policies will not allow us to meet our climate targets and obligations unless further piecemeal, contentious and hideously costly steps are taken along these same paths. Second, current and likely future similar policies will damage our productivity. Third, policies without a carbon price provide no funds to compensate households for the cost of these policies. Fourth, current and likely future policies damage rather than contribute to necessary budget repair.”
Professor Rod Sims
Chair of the Superpower Institute

On gas, Shell’s Australia business head Cecile Wake said the “false choice” between domestic supply and exports undermines investment, deters exploration, and threatens supply, calling for policies that “encourage new development, not penalise success”. (AFR)

Gas and electricity prices will rise by 2% for millions of British households under the latest cap announced by energy regulator Ofgem. The increase means a household using a typical amount of energy will pay £1,755 a year, up £35 a year on the current cap. Ofgem sets the quarterly price cap by using a formula that reflects wholesale energy prices, suppliers' network costs and environmental and social levies. Wholesale energy prices fell around 2% over the latest assessment period. (BBC) (Reuters)

A new series from UK-based website Carbon Brief fact checks 16 myths about solar power. The group said misinformation campaigns were impacting policy around the world, with governments restricting and sometimes banning the installation of solar panels across swathes of land. (Carbon Brief)

High US tariffs on Indian solar panel exports are expected to exacerbate a supply glut in India next year, forcing it to find new markets. (Reuters)


Regulation

A transparency review by the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) of the Australian Energy Market Operator’s (AEMO) Inputs, Assumptions and Scenarios Report (IASR), used to develop the 2026 Integrated System Plan (ISP) found AEMO did not adequately explain how data centre energy consumption forecasts were derived. Nor did AEMO explain how policies identified as affecting consumer demand such as battery subsidies were used. AER also wants to know how AEMO derived the proportion of hydrogen production that is based in a Renewable Energy Zone (REZ), its assumption that all non-REZ hydrogen production is off-grid, what this means for the proportion of hydrogen production that is assumed to be grid-connected, and assumptions about the cost of hydrogen infrastructure.


Technology

The Delft University of Technology's Brunel team from the Netherlands took out the 2025 World Solar Challenge after dozens of teams from around the world raced 3,000km from Darwin to Adelaide in solar-powered vehicles. Brunel's victory comes after the team placed third in 2023, and a car fire forced it out of the 2019 race. (ABC)

US-based Commonwealth Fusion Systems (CFS) announced its latest fundraising, with super fund Hostplus among backers in the oversubscribed round. The almost US$3 billion CFS has raised to date is about one-third of the total capital invested in private fusion companies worldwide. CFS plans to have a “commercially relevant” fusion machine ready in 2027 at its campus in Massachusetts. It also plans to build the world’s first grid-scale fusion power plant and put power on the grid in the early 2030s, with tech giant Google locked in as an offtake partner for half the power from the proposed plant in Virginia.


Climate

The environment’s adaptation to climate change is dependent on water but projecting how water resources will be impacted in the future is difficult. To support climate change adaptation, Charles Darwin University (CDU) researchers have developed a guide, published in the journal Earth’s Future, to making hydrological projections working alongside with experts from CSIRO, New Zealand’s GNS Science (now Earth Science NZ) and climate services company Acclimatised.

“Getting the right modelling outputs from the scientists that will allow water resource managers to inform and adapt their policies and water allocation limits is essential. This guide can help them understand the process, technical jargon and the basis of the climate and hydrological modelling science to better drive the outputs that scientists will prepare for them.”
Frédérique Mourot
CDU PhD candidate

People

Climateworks Centre’s Chair and co-founder Professor John Thwaites announced his retirement from a formal leadership role. He will remain a professor at Monash University and continue to support sustainability and climate change initiatives.

“John leaves a legacy of resolute focus on impact and achieving Climateworks’ mission to drive emissions reduction at scale and with urgency.”
Anna Skarbek
Climateworks CEO

Research

The Melbourne Energy Institute - in partnership with the University of Melbourne, the University of Queensland and Princeton University - announced the next phase of the Net Zero Australia Project that will undertake deeper analysis of the decarbonisation challenge and make practical recommendations. Quarterly reports will tackle key questions, including:

  • How can we improve the planning and implementation of large-scale decarbonisation initiatives?
  • How can land use support natural ecosystems, agriculture and carbon management whilst enabling the rapid roll out of clean energy infrastructure?
  • What measures are needed to benefit local communities, mobilise the required workforce and engage households in the clean energy transition?

UNSW Energy Institute CEO Dani Alexander and Industry Professor of Practice Mark Twidell explain why “digital twinning” is essential in the step change to renewables. (Renew Economy)

What's On

September 1-3
Farming Forever National Summit

Farmers for Climate Action CEO Natalie Collard, Rewiring Aeteroa CEO Mike Casey, NSW EnergyCo Chair Paul Binsted, ANU Director of the Institute for Climate, Energy & Disaster Solutions Professor Mark Howden and NAB Chief Climate Officer Jacqui Fox will speak at this Farmers for Climate Action event in Canberra.


September 2
Bias in action

ANU Institute for Infrastructure in Society Director Sara Bice, CEO of The Energy Charter Sabiene Heindl, Director of Partnerships and Engagement at Energy Estate Rosie King, and Head of Communications and Stakeholder Engagement at Ark Energy Melissa Pisani will speak at this renewable energy engagement webinar.


September 2-4
14th World Chambers Congress

OECD Secretary-General Mathias Cormann, CEFC Chair Steven Skala and Yurringa Energy CEO Arron Wood are among the speakers at this Melbourne event.


September 3
The case for an Australian clean commodities trading initiative

UNSW Professor of International Political Economy Elizabeth Thurbon and Australian country head of GAW Capital Oliver Yates will speak at this Curtin Institute for Energy Transition webinar.


September 3-4
NT Resources Week

SunCable CEO Ryan Willemsen-Bell, Northern Australia Infrastructure Facility Chair Tracey Hayes, Arafura Rare Earths CEO Darryl Cuzzubbo, Director of the Gas & Energy Transition Research Centre at UQ Professor David Close, and CSIRO Hydrogen Industry Mission Lead Dr Patrick G. Hartley will speak at this Darwin event, which includes a Clean Energy and Decarbonisation stream.


September 10
The NEM Review: Your questions answered

In this follow-up webinar, Tim Nelson and the NEM Review panel reconvene with The Energy’s Advisory Board Chair Simon Corbell to answer your questions about the draft report.


September 16
The Price of Power: The Future of Australia's Energy Sector

Bluescope Chief Executive, Climate Change and Sustainability Deborah Caudle, Alinta Energy CEO Jeff Dimery, AGL CEO Damien Nicks and Australian Energy Council CEO Louisa Kinnear will speak at this American Chamber of Commerce event in Melbourne, with R. Blair Thomas, CEO of US energy investment firm EIG speaking via Zoom.


September 23
AEMO's Annual Results

Australian Energy Market Operator CEO Daniel Westerman and Executive General Manager for Finance and Governance Vanessa Hannan will outline progress against strategic priorities and initiatives, financial results for FY25 and priorities for FY26.


September 24
Updated net zero pathways for Australia

The Net Zero Australia Project team from the University of Melbourne, the University of Queensland and Princeton University will present their latest report on the roles of renewables, energy storage and firming including nuclear, carbon capture and storage and other complementary technologies at this hybrid event.

The Energy

The Energy is dedicated to covering the business of energy and in particular the people, capital, projects and emerging technology behind the energy transition.

Read more from The Energy

Hey Reader, in today's edition: Getting off diesel Environmental law reform explained TagEnergy grows portfolio Diesel addiction threatens 2030 target Australia will fail to reach its 2030 emissions reduction target, let alone deeper cuts by 2035, if heavy industries don’t reduce their diesel use, scientists warn. A report released at Parliament House by the Australian Academy of Technological Sciences & Engineering (ATSE) and mining giant Fortescue (ASX: FMG) takes a look – fuel by fuel – at...

Hey Reader, welcome to The Energy's weekly data newsletter. This week we explore the impact the energy wars are having on consumer perceptions of clean energy. Australian support for clean energy Two new consumer polls on attitudes towards renewable energy provide some of the data behind the wedge politics seen in parliament this week. Debate on Nationals MP Barnaby Joyce’s private members bill to repeal climate laws on Monday quickly moved onto renewable energy targets and Nationals MP...

Hey Reader, in today's edition: Preparing for a fully renewable system Measuring public support for the transition 2035 target looms Record investment in the NEM The annual State of the energy market report shows more than 5GW of new solar, wind, battery and gas capacity entered the National Electricity Market (NEM) in 2024 - the largest annual new entry of capacity since the NEM began in 1998. On 6 November 2024, renewable sources supplied 75.6% of total generation during the half-hour...