Stopping the energy wars


Hey Reader, welcome to The Energy. In today's edition:

  • Stopping the energy wars
  • Landmark 'greenwashing' case settles
  • Australian-made electric trucks

Australia has the makings of an energy ceasefire

In the final of his three-part series on stopping the energy wars, Dan Cass reminds us of energy transition agreements of the past and posits a way forward — if the politicians can stop the brickbats.

Expert view

"Australia was promised that a high-tech energy future would begin in 2025 but we got an election that dished up the past.

Following the 2016 SA blackout, ministers from the big four parties, Liberal, Labor, National and Greens, agreed to find ways to keep electricity reliable and secure, as coal retired.

An Integrated System Plan would build Renewable Energy Zones to bring cheap solar and wind to cities and factories, through thousands of kilometres of transmission lines.

By 2025 Australia would have a future-proof new electricity system. The four parties disagreed about climate goals but they did agree to keep the lights on and prices down. At least, they promised to.

Instead, Peter Dutton, the Liberal leader, brought an intellectual blackout. The Liberals and Nationals campaigned for nuclear and against renewables. With no credible plan, costing or emissions target.

Given how high the climate and political stakes are, it is worth considering a big new idea.

Dan Cass
Research Affiliate, Sydney Environment Institute

Landmark 'greenwashing' case settles

The Parents for Climate advocacy organisation reached a settlement with EnergyAustralia after mounting a court challenge claiming 400,000 customers were misled about the “Go Neutral” product. (AAP)

Represented by Equity Generation Lawyers, the Federal Court case was the first in Australia to be brought against a company for “carbon neutral” marketing and the first time an Australian energy retailer faced legal action for alleged greenwashing.

Background to the case:

  • EnergyAustralia is Australia’s third-largest domestic greenhouse gas emitter and one of the nation’s “big three” gentailers
  • Parents for Climate is a 20,000-member climate advocacy organisation
  • EnergyAustralia offered “Go Neutral Electricity” and “Go Neutral Gas” products whereby carbon credits offset the emissions associated with the energy supply
  • But paying someone else an “avoidance” credit was not equivalent to removing the emissions generated to supply the electricity and gas, Parents for Climate argued
  • EnergyAustralia withdrew its “Go Neutral” products for new customers in November.

EnergyAustralia, which aims to be “carbon neutral” by 2050, has said it remains committed to offering customers clean energy.

The closure of its coal-fired Yallourn Power Station, slated for 2028, is expected to slash the company's emissions profile by 60%.

Keep on trucking

Volvo will make the first Australian-made heavy duty electric trucks at its Wacol facility in Brisbane next year. The pivotal announcement for local manufacturing - and freight’s carbon footprint - coincided with a delivery of heavy duty electric trucks to logistics giant Linfox.

“Further electrifying our fleet sets the standard for us and our customers and the entire industry.” — Executive Chairman of Linfox Peter Fox

The transport sector is Australia’s third-largest emitter, accounting for 21% of greenhouse gas emissions. Within freight, road transport accounts for more than 80% of emissions.

Volvo said building the electric trucks here would expand Australia’s manufacturing capabilities, accelerate adoption, and reduce road transport emissions.

“To assist the industry accelerate the adoption of low emission electric trucks, we would like to see all state and federal governments provide more accessible incentives for all businesses, especially small to medium enterprises, so they can follow in Linfox’s footsteps.” — President of Volvo Group Australia Martin Merrick

Meanwhile, strong Chinese demand pushed global EV sales to 20% of market share, according to the IEA’s latest data, while the US fell further behind on electric cars. (ABC) (CleanTechnica)

Catch up

Capital

Gina RInehart backed gas explorer Lakes Blue Energy launched a $10 million capital raise, pitching itself as a likely beneficiary of gas shortfalls on Australia’s East Coast. (AFR)

Alex Wonhas-led renewables developer Ampyr Energy Global is seeking investors in the first stage of its 400 MW Wellington battery. (AFR)

Queensland Treasurer and Energy Minister David Janetzki released a Strengthening Social Impact in Queensland issues paper for feedback. The Office of Social Impact is developing a roadmap for social enterprise and impact investors and an $80 million Social Entrepreneurs Fund.


Projects

A $70 million planned overhaul is underway at coal-fired Tarong North Power Station, which still provides a fifth of Queensland’s energy needs. Expected to run until early July, the project will create an extra 500 short-term specialised contractor roles on site.

“Each unit undergoes a major overhaul every four years to keep them running optimally year-round. An overhaul is a big job and typically takes 12 months to plan before it even starts. Once the work kicks off it involves extensive inspection, maintenance, refurbishment and replacement of plant and equipment.” — Stanwell General Manager Southern Generation Mick Joy

Meanwhile Central Queensland’s Banana Shire is gearing up for a $40 billion renewable energy project pipeline.

“This is about more than just clean energy. It's about long-term benefits for our local economy, our workforce, and our towns.” — Mayor Nev Ferrier

Policy

Analysts Wood Mackenzie warned Australia would not meet its renewable energy target of 82% by 2030, forecasting it would instead be 58% by the end of the decade. It said the government needed to “overcome roadblocks in grid connection and planning processes, ensure a smooth transition and meet planned coal plant closure timeframes”. (Reuters)

The US House Energy and Commerce Committee approved rollbacks for Biden-era energy programs in an omnibus bill that includes a “pay-to-play” scheme for fossil fuel developers to pay a fee to have their projects deemed in the public interest. (Politico)


Regulation

The ‘loyalty tax’ energy consumers pay for not shopping around is in the sights of Victoria’s Essential Services Commission. The regulator proposed a series of rule changes to the Energy Retail Code of Practice including one that would require energy retailers to move customers that have been on the same plan for 4 years onto a more reasonable rate. The ESC also wants to see consumers receiving assistance under the Payment Difficulty Framework or in arrears for at least three months and with arrears above $1,000 moved onto the cheapest plan.

The Australian Energy Regulator proposed to increase the minimum disconnection amount to $500 in a draft decision after a review of payment difficulty protections found room for improvement for electricity and gas retailers.

TasNetworks says many recommendations are already being implemented, after an inquiry found they weren’t equipped to handle a 2024 storm event. (ABC)

New Zealand’s Cabinet approved energy security regulations that give fuel companies until November 1, 2026, to increase the jet fuel they hold at or near the Auckland Airport to safeguard the economy against unexpected fuel supply disruptions.

“Fuel companies have allowed jet fuel cover to fall below the (2019) inquiry’s recommended resilience target of 10 days’ cover at 80 per cent operations, leaving New Zealand susceptible to the impacts of an unexpected fuel supply disruption. The regulations provide the extra impetus fuel companies need to avoid any further delay for investing in additional fuel storage.” — New Zealand Associate Energy Minister Shane Jones

Technology

US officials are investigating after "rogue communication devices" were found in Chinese-made solar inverters. (Reuters)

One of the smallest local government organisations in Australia is one of the first councils to install off-grid public solar street lighting in a new residential development. Solar lighting technology company Leadsun and Murrumbidgee Council in the Riverina region of NSW installed the technology throughout the new River Red Gum Estate.

“Not only do these lights utilise renewable solar energy, but their design eliminates the need for traditional in-ground cabling, which reduces both installation costs and environmental impact. Additionally, the built-in motion sensors allow the lights to adjust intelligently to movement, optimising energy use while maintaining safety and visibility for the estate.” — Mayor Ruth McRae

Climate

Microsoft signed a deal with carbon credit management firm Rubicon Carbon that it said was one of the largest-ever commitments by a single corporate buyer in the voluntary carbon market to date. The deal is expected to finance the extraction of 18 million tons of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere via tree planting and land restoration.

A study from the LobbyMap platform found a profound shift in corporate attitudes toward climate policy among businesses in the European Union. The findings challenge narratives promoted by certain industry associations and contrast with recent political and economic developments that may appear to deprioritise the climate agenda. The EU’s ability to fulfil its climate commitments is expected to depend on the impact of corporate advocacy on the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism revision, sectoral decarbonisation, and energy sector policies for electricity and gas in the Affordable Energy Action Plan.


People

The Greens elected Senator for Queensland Larissa Waters as leader in an uncontested ballot.

“The Greens will be firm but constructive in our approach with the Labor government, and work for outcomes that help improve peoples’ lives and protect nature and the climate.
“I thank my party room colleagues for their unanimous support today, and I also want to pay tribute to Adam Bandt for his leadership and dedication to our movement over the last 15 years.” — Australian Greens Leader Larissa Waters

Quinbrook Infrastructure Partners announced the expansion of its Relationships and Fundraising Team with new senior appointments: Ryan Gordon joins Quinbrook after 18 years with QIC, while Jonathan Borland joins from DWS Infrastructure. Gordon succeeds Rob Kerr, currently Quinbrook’s Managing Director, Head of Capital Formation and Investor Engagement, APAC, who will leave the firm at the end of July.


Research

A ‘semi-regulated’ policy framework designed to reduce the financing burden on capital-intensive, ultra-long-lived assets like pumped hydro could cut carrying costs by nearly 40% and help to deliver lower power prices, according to new research by Griffith University Professor Paul Simshauser and PhD candidate Nicholas Ghodes.

China’s clean power generation growth has for the first time been behind a fall in the nation’s CO2 emissions levels, according to new analysis from Carbon Brief. Looking at official figures and commercial data, it found electricity supply from new wind, solar and nuclear capacity was enough to cut coal-power output even as demand surged, whereas previous falls were due to weak growth.


Random

Exclusion lists driven by facial recognition, opaque security contractors, invasive physical searches, out-of-the-way locations, and guards who follow shareholders to the toilet - this is the new reality of attending AGMs of major London-listed fossil fuel companies, writes leading shareholder activist Brynn O’Brien.

What's on

May 16
AEMO consultation - cyber security

Submissions on the draft report on whether AEMO’s cyber security roles and responsibilities should be a declared NEM project are due.


May 21-22
Australian Renewable Energy Zones conference

​Australian Energy Infrastructure Commissioner Tony Mahar will speak along with EnergyCo CEO Hannah McCaughey and NSW Energy and Water Ombudsman Janine Young at this Sydney event.


May 21-22
Hunter New Energy Symposium

Raymond Hohle, Executive Manager Projects and Assets - Port of Newcastle, Heidi Lee, CEO - Beyond Zero Emissions and Tim Buckley, Director - Climate Energy Finance (CEF) will keynote at this Newcastle event.


May 26
Labor's landslide: What's next for energy and climate policy in Australia?

Simon Corbell, advisory board Chair, The Energy will moderate this webinar featuring Climate Change Authority Chair Matt Kean, DER strategy specialist Gabrielle Kuiper, Windlab CEO John Martin, and DPG Advisory Solutions Director Climate and ESG Ben Oquist.


May 28-29
H2 2 ZERO Summit 2025

New Zealand’s Energy Minister Simon Watts, Japan’s Ambassador to NZ Makoto Osawa, and Rocket Lab Founder Sir Peter Beck are among diplomats, business leaders and researchers speaking at this event in Wellington.

The Energy

The Energy is dedicated to covering the business of energy and in particular the people, capital, projects and emerging technology behind the energy transition.

Read more from The Energy

Hey Reader, welcome to The Energy. In today's edition: Waiting for V2G Green bank supports small business solving big business problems Why the answer to Yallourn's closure is not gas Gas decision wins no friends Slow burn for future grid's 'gamechanger' You can readily see why vehicle-to-grid charging — offering win-win benefits for customers, grid operators and the environment — is an emerging hot topic for the energy transition. In practice, realising these benefits is likely to be a slow...

Hey Reader, welcome to The Energy's weekly data newsletter. This week we explore carbon capture and the gap between its promise and delivery in the energy transition. Close, but no cigar If ever there was a picture that aptly summed up the gap between the promise and reality of carbon capture and storage, it‘s this one. Announced and operational carbon capture, utilisation and storage capacity It comes from the International Energy Agency’s recent update to its Carbon Capture, Utilisation and...

Hey Reader, welcome to The Energy. In today's edition: Energy policy continuity welcomed Methane action to offset credibility leakage Call for one-stop approvals shop Energy policy continuity in new Cabinet Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s full ministry will be sworn in on Tuesday morning with the existing energy transition team joined by a new advocate for industrial decarbonisation and a special envoy who will be put through her paces if Australia hosts COP talks. Chris Bowen was...